Mary Beth Writes

Go ahead, ask me what I’ve been doing lately…

The movie we watched is Nomadland directed by Chloe Zhao.

In 2018 I wrote this review of Nomadland by Jessica Bruder. (Read here) The book is nonfiction and was so powerful that two years later, it still affects how I think about being old in our nation.

Friday night Len and I streamed the new Nomadland movie. The movie is well done, most of the actors are actual folks who live the camper/van nomad life. The story respects Fern, the character played by Frances McDormand.

Nevertheless. Where the movie goes with Bruder’s book bothers me a lot. Zhao shapes the storyline to be about the personal evolution of Fern as she comes to value her own toughness and independence. But, this is weird, the second half of the movie is comprised mostly of scenes that don’t exist in the book.

Respecting the toughness of older women is powerful, yes, but is not what the book was about. The book was a researched examination of how fraught it is to be aging and financially broke in this society now.

I think the movie disarms the power of the book. In our tough and dangerous economic world, I find that dishonest.

I wrote a review of Overstory by Richard Powers a couple weeks ago. (Read here) I liked and didn’t like the novel.

In response to my somewhat cranky review of Overstory, my friend Michol lent me her copy of a beautiful book that I read in two afternoons; The Hidden Life of Trees / illustrated edition. The author, Peter Wohlleben is a botanist caretaker of a forest under restoration in Germany. His book is clearly written over-sized book about trees, plant life, and the ginormous understructure of fungi that scientists are just beginning to research. It has gorgeous photographs every few pages and would be an excellent present for anyone who loves nature and photography. (The photo that heads today’s post is one of the book’s photos.)

Apparently one can also obtain Wohlleben’s book in a more elongated version with no photographs.

After months of waiting, my copy of Braiding Sweetgrass by Robin Wall Kimmerer arrived. It’s so popular it’s not renewable!

Let me just mention right here - I’m curious why the universe is giving me all these books about trees! I didn’t think I was this interested, but here I am.

The subtitle of Braiding Sweetgrass tells you the theme of Kimmerer’s book of essays. “Indigenous Wisdom, Scientific Knowledge, and the Teachings of Plants.”

Kimmerer is an enrolled member of the Anishinaabe nation; she belongs to Potawatomi people. She also has a PhD in botany and has studied plants all her life. Her book is a connected compendium of essays describing her life interacting with plants as a scientist and as an indigenous person. Her essays are fascinating.

The essay that astonished me most is “Learning the Grammar of Animacy.” She describes the revelation it was to try to learn the native Ojibwe language her grandfather spoke before forced boarding schools stripped native kids of their mother language. Kimmerer has spent years trying to learn her own language.

There is this: We know ourselves via the language that we speak. English is mostly nouns, with about 30% verbs. Ojibwe is 70% verbs. Much of English is about delineating gender. Anishinaabe doesn’t divide the world into sex.

Anishinaabe DOES describe the world according to the nature and properties of how things are changing, moving, growing, or interconnecting to something else. The example she uses is that a bay of water is not a bay. The Ojibwe word for bay is translated to a VERB meaning “to be a bay.” As if it might be something else tomorrow, which since a bay is filled with water, it might be. The bay is not the static noun where three sides of land are filled with water. A bay is the moving interconnection of trees, water entering from streams and springs, water moving outward to the lake or river, the interconnected life that happens in and around a bay. The bay is animate.

What she learns is that her native language not about what things are now, but about how things are connected. One does not own things. One is in a relationship for a day or a lifetime and the language speaks to that.

Her scientific PhD is important to her and she values it. She explains that much of western science is about breaking entities down to see and understand the parts. Indigenous language is about seeing the connections. Both are needed to build a path for all of earth.

FYI because this has confused me for years: As clearly as I understand Native nations names, Anishinaabe is single umbrella name for the large and culturally interconnected nations that covered the massive woodlands that once covered most of Canada and the US from the Great Lakes to the Atlantic. Within that overarching interconnection were smaller (though still very sizeable) nations such as Ojibwe, Odawa, Saulteaux, Potawatomi, Oji-Cree, and Algonquin peoples. 

I am reading more widely than I have read in years. I’ve always read a lot, but within genres that made paths for me through my life; novels of girls and women and men.

I’m still mostly a novel reader, but this past year I’ve discovered National Book Awards winners and runners-up. Still tales about people, but incredibly well-written novels of characters whose lives and cultures are more consistently different than mine. 

Also, to give credit where credit is due, I read the website The Nonconsumer Advocate.  People who look for ways to live more frugally and lightly on the earth tend to be readers and thinkers. Nomadland, Overstory, and Braiding Sweetgrass all came to my attention via the NCA. I put notes of interesting sounding books in my phone’s note app and when I order books from the library, I order from that haphazard list.

And Bob’s your reading uncle.



Thank you, Mary Beth for the great book reviews and the website link to THe Nonconsumer Advocate. It's wonderful to explore and add to my lists these horizon expanders. I read a book a while ago - "Bringing Nature Home: How Native Plants Sustain Wildlife In Our Gardens" by Doug Tallamy. In addition to advocating for native plants in our yards, he explains some of the interactions between native plants, insects, and animals that is amazing and fascinating. He is Professor and Chair of the Departmant of Entomololgy and Wildlife Ecology at the University of Delaware. He has written other books, which I haven't gotten to yet.
Mary Beth's picture

Thanks for responding. It's so cool to be reading about plants - and discover the world of plants and trees lives and breathes on the same growth of interconnections that we intuit and feel in so much of the best parts of our lives.

I’m listening to Braiding Sweetgrass! It is so interesting and also is really relaxing and helps me sleep. I might have to get it again, because I’m missing the second half of each chapter. I really enjoyed the chapter about Witch Hazel.
Mary Beth's picture

She is such a good writer. When she started describing witch hazel, I knew what she was talking about even though I had never known the name of those shrubs before. "Tattered yellow rag ribbons in November."

Prompting from NCA and your post I also read Nomadland 2 years ago, and was profoundly moved by the book ( it also cemented my anti Amazon stance). I found the movie good, but coming from the perspective of the book, I was disappointed. However, as a middle aged widow navigating life (different financial circumstances), I found a certain sisterhood, and kinship with Fern. Also, Frances McDormand... I want to be her friend. Thank you always for your posts. Patricia
Mary Beth's picture

I know! The movie was good! It just wasn't the point of the book... I've read that most of those people in the movie really are "nomads" ... and they didn't realize Frances McDormand is a movie star!

I have been reading more than ever, too (and I read a lot before!) AND I've branched out to other genres, along with making a point to read women of color authors more than I did (which was hardly ever). All that to say...yes, there are so many books. How does one read them all??? My list is always full but I can only place 20 holds at our library. So end up Thriftbooking because I can't stand waiting. :) Nothing to do with trees: but I just {re}read Hunger by Roxane Gay and cannot recommend it enough. It should be required reading for humans. Side note: we planed a witch hazel in the front garden last spring & I cannot WAIT to see how it grows.
Mary Beth's picture

I just saw on PBS Tonight that in March their featured readers' discussion book will be Nomadland. I'm glad. A lot of people will probably follow along, and that can only help the conversation. I've heard that Hunger is a good read. Will put it on the list...

Add new comment


This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

The Lies We Live By


Aristotle wrote a lot of important stuff, very little of which I’ve read. But this Aristotelian idea is cool and I don’t know why we are not taught this in high school. It helps untangle the importance of what we read and watch.

Fat Tuesday & Valentines Day & Ash Wednesday (says it all)


I think today has to be a Three Things. You probably don’t even know I have Three Things scaffolding in my secret writing toolbox of organizational tools, but I do. Sometimes it’s how thoughts present themselves, you know? Things to say, but not for too long.

(Now that I've finished and read what I wrote, I guess this is five things but some days, in our expanding universe, the math just works this way,)

Successful & Failed Artists


Last week I finished reading Woodcutters by Thomas Bernhard. (I discovered this book via Librarian of Burgos Instagram because I am her fangirl now.)

If you like to read a book that has a recognizable plot of sympathetic characters moving forward through a problem to a solution– you will likely not enjoy this novel. Heck, I’m not sure if I ‘enjoyed’ it.

Animals of Winter


Last week I invited you to submit pictures of animals who are visiting your life these days.

The Republic of False Truths


I set a goal for this year to read one translated modern novel every month. I’ve been following ‘Librarian of Burgos’ on Instagram and this woman keeps hyping and explaining books I’ve never heard of, which intrigues me mightily. I think she might be a reader’s reader. Anyways, she is European, has transcendently luminous skin plus several master’s degrees and a doctorate in history. Sometimes she even recommends books that are not, sadly she says, not yet translated into English. Cracks me up.

Who's In Your Backyard?


It’s been a wowser of a wintery week. We had the deep and blowing snow last Friday which turned into the heavy-as-concrete snow on Saturday which turned into a deep and frozen crust on Sunday - and here we still are. Last week’s snow still limns the trees and branches. A foot of snow still covers every roof. When I walk (why yes, I’m still going out for strolls) it’s a matter of life and limb navigating the jagged piles between sidewalk and street. I do use my “Alpine” walking stick these days.

Change is coming but not today.

Tag Cloud

9/11 17 minutes 500 Words A-Z AARPtaxes AAUW abortion Acadia accident Accountable Advent aging Alaska animals anniversary antibiotics antlers apples appointments Arrows art Ashland August Augustine aunts baby Badlands balance Baldwin Barbara Barkskins Beauty Becky Becoming Esther Berry birthday bistro BLM Blue BookReport books Boxing Day boy scout Bread breakfast BreakfastClub BrokenDays BuyAngry Cabeza de Vaca Cahokia calendars Canada canoe cat romance cats cello Chicago China Choosing Christmas cilantro Cinnabuns circus climate change clouds Clowns clutter Colonialism comet ComfortZone CommonSense community consumerism Cops Corvid-19 Courage Covid-19 Crazy creditreport creosote crime CrimeShows danger DarkRiver death Debate December DecisionFatigue decluttering deer democracy dentist depression Destination Today Detroit Didion disasterprep distraction dogs dollhouse Dreams Duty Easter eBay Echoes Eclipse election EmilyDickinson eschatology Esquipulas exit polls eyes Fable FairTrade family farmer Fata Morgana ferns firealarm Fitness Five Flatbread Flexible flu Food Pantry Fort de Chartres frame Franc FrancGarcia friends frugal FrugalHacks Frugality frustration Ft.Ticonderoga fungi fusion Galena Gannets Garden GarfieldParkConservatory Gaspe genius geode GeorgeFloyd gerrymandering ghosts gifts girls GNTL gorgons goulash GovernorThompsonStatePark Graduation grandkids granola Grief groceries Guadalupe Guatemala gum guns Hair happiness HaveYouEver? hawks healthcare Healthinsurance hearings heart heaven HelleKBerry heroes hike History home HomeRepair Honduras Hope HowCrowGotOutofJail humor hurricane Ice Cream idiosyncrasy igloos impeachment Innkeeper Instincts integrity InternetPrivacy Interview InviteMe2Speak James Baldwin Jan 6 Janus jewelry JoyceAndrews Judy JulianofNorwich Jump justice Karen kites ladder Lady Lamb LangstonHuges LaphamPeak laundry LeeLeeMcKnight lemming Len lies Light Lincoln Little Women LockedOut Loki loneliness LouisArmstrong Love Ludington Macaw macho Manitoulin MargaretFuller Maria Hamilton Marquette marriage Marsden Hartley masks Mayan MayaWorks meme Memories men Middlemarch MilesWallyDiego MindfulChickens Mistakes MLK moon Mother MothersDay mounds mouser movies museums must-haves Mustapha NAMI Nancy Drew Newfoundland New Mexico New York City Nomadland nope observation OBUUC Ocotillo OnaJudge ordinary OscarRomero osprey Outside oximeter Parade mayhem PastorBettyRendon Paul Hessert PDQ Penny persimmon photos Pi Pies pineapples pizza poetry Preaching privacy procrastination Protest QE2 Quern quest Questions Rabbit holes racism reading recipe recipes recommendations Remember RepresentationMatters Reruns responsetoKapenga Retirement rhubarb Ricky rime RitesofPassage romance Rosemary Ruether Roses Roti Ruth SamaritanWoman Sanctuary Sandhillcranes Santuario de Chimayo SaraKurtz SaraRodriguez satellites sci-fi ScottSimon sculpture Seasons Sermon ServantsoftheQuest sewing Shepherd Shontay ShortStory shoulder sick sickness Slower snow Social Security SofritoBandito solstice South Dakota SpaceShuttle spirituality spring square feet St. Louis staining stars stele Stereotypes stories StoryStarts stream monitoring stress SUBSTACK Survival swim Talent taxes teenager thankgsgiving Thanksgiving TheBridge TheMaid ThePerpetualYou therapy ThreeBillBoards Three Thing Three Things ThreeThings TidalBore TimeBeing toddler Tom tortillas Trains travel Traveler Tubing turtle Twilight Bark Tyrone Ukraine Ulysses Grant Umbrella UnrelatedObservations Up North urgency vacation vaccine Valentines vanilla Vietnam vision VivianWokeUpDrowning Vocabulary vole volunteer WalkingAndSeeing Wampanaog war WarsanShire weather weaving Webs wedding whines WhyAttendChurch Wiley Willa WillaCather Wisteria Won! Wonder words Xeriscape Yellowstone Zebra
Ad Promotion