Mary Beth Writes

1/19/2024

I set a goal for this year to read one translated modern novel every month. I’ve been following ‘Librarian of Burgos’ on Instagram and this woman keeps hyping and explaining books I’ve never heard of, which intrigues me mightily. I think she might be a reader’s reader. Anyways, she is European, has transcendently luminous skin plus several master’s degrees and a doctorate in history. Sometimes she even recommends books that are not, sadly she says, not yet translated into English. Cracks me up.

She recommended The Republic of False Truths by Alaa Alaswany (my library notifies via a cover sticker that in the US his name is spelled Ala Aswani). It took me a month to read; it’s not an easy story. There were a few pages I had to skim/skip because they described assault and torture.

Alaswany is a well-known and highly regarded Egyptian writer. He now lives outside Egypt because he is not safe there.

The book is set in the Arab Spring Revolution of 2011. There are a number of characters who, you will discover after a while, are connected to each other. There are heartfelt, brilliant, earnest young adults who, at great risk, join the protests in Tahrir Square and elsewhere. There are powerful men and women who do not want to revolution to succeed. There are victims, heroes, perpetrators of utter evil. And then there is the general population of Egyptians who have to decide how they are going to think and believe, what they are going to do, and how much, if anything, they are willing to sacrifice to support the revolution that is for them.

This book scared me. It rings bells we are hearing in our western societies. It's a story of a modern Egypt trying to free itself from the manipulative power and corruption of the ultra-rich and ultra powerful. This is not unknown to us.

Here are some of the notes and points I made for myself as I was reading it:

Egypt, as portrayed by Alaswany, is dominated by conservative Islam religion. Women are second tier citizens expected to be submissive and modest. Good partnerships built on love and respect exist, but it isn’t common nor is it a life goal of most typical couples. It’s fine for men to regard wives and daughters as property, accessories, or servants. Humans can transcend these limitations but the accepted practice of religion doesn’t challenge these attitudes. When young women decide to live their lives as champions of fairness and justice, not only is this hard, it’s almost impossible. Fathers and bosses feel entitled to limit the options and freedom of their daughters or wives.

Shutting down the free movement and adult choices for half the population means every time you see a woman trying hard to do her job in a way that respects the poor and unpowerful, you are seeing a woman who had to figure out how to live within or leave her own family first. Young men have to go through one layer of themselves to join the revolution. Women have to go through two.

As one young woman says, “I believe in my opinions. I love my family. Both of these are true.” But she cannot live out both of these truths; she has to pick one and walk away from the other.

Powerful people don’t have to explain or defend themselves. They just act. People who oppose corrupt power have to talk all the time; among themselves, to the public, to the powerful people. They have to learn how to use media. Powerful people just use their ‘same ole, same ole” lies, threats, and violence.

When creating and sustaining a revolution to fight corruption and bring justice, one needs the support of the “ordinary people” of that society. The thing is, most ordinary citizens are passionate about their own rights but not about the rights of others. The ongoing work of any movement towards “justice for all” is to figure out how to educate people to care about more than just themselves and their own community.

Tell me about it.

We see a loving relationship between two people who are both married to other people. There is a backstory here that I won’t tell you, but our respect and sympathy lay with these two. She asks him at one point what their future can possibly be. He says, “In our situation it’s wrong to think of the future.”

To love in a revolution is to give up the busyness and satisfaction of arranging our personal future? This is so close to so many of the enigmatic sayings of Jesus.

The powerful call up their very rich and powerful imam when they have questions of how to act. The imam tells them “Necessity permits the prohibited.” When the TV news anchor puts on the head covering, that’s when she becomes evilly duplicitous. Her religious leader does not ask her to seek justice. He says, in veiled terms, that it’s okay to lie in order to preserve the status quo of yore.

Religion brought to us by rich, publically pious, and powerful religious leaders is always suspect.

A shivering line as authorities quash and quell the revoluti0on. “In Egypt the authorities are capable of failing at everything except the subjugation of the Egyptians.”

One man says, “Am I drinking to forget or to remember?”

The only characters who can continue past the timeline of the book are those few people who are not waiting for resolution. The ones who endure until they are imprisoned are the ones who accept getting up every morning to continue to live in and fight against conflict and craziness.

This moved me. We need to stop looking for “when it will get sane again.” We need to remember that it was never sane, that the calmness we fondly remember was built on the exploitation of others.

Weirdly, I find this comforting. It’s wasted energy to long for the past. Peace and love can only survive where there is respect and justice.

 

Tags

Comments

As a white male gay citizen of the US, I live in a mostly privileged world on safety built on an empire of global economic domination based upon predatory capitalism. It preys and feeds upon the corrupt places in the world that oppress their own people for financial gain. Oppressed people rise up. Sometimes they prevail. But mostly do not. I imagine The Republic of False Truths tells the Egyptian story of this reality with compelling imagery. Syria, Ukraine, Gaza, El Salvador, Guatemala, Belgian Congo, South Africa, Russia, the 400 years in the American South. Over and over again. throughout history. Thanks for sharing your personal thoughts in your journey through this intriguing lens of the Egyptian experience.
Mary Beth's picture

What caught my respect and attention was his critique. respect, criticism of the masses of ordinary Egyptian citizens. There are two (in love) characters who, over the period of the revolution and it's later dissolution, who will take different stances against the entrenched determination of the majority of exploited people to get back to the "status quo." Ashwani writes both sides. Its so infuriating and sad.

So often your writing comes at a time when I am thinking precisely about the very topic: "most ordinary citizens are passionate about their own rights, but not about the rights of others." I will add this book to my ever growing list of must reads. Thank you always. Patricia
Mary Beth's picture

Thank you, too. Empathy is, apparently, an extravagant and hard to win virtue.

I am reading a translated book right now. The Librarian of Auschwitz by Antonio Iturbe, translated by Lilit Zekulin Thwaites. It based on the true story of an Auschwitz prisoner. It is also a hard story to read.
Mary Beth's picture

Translated literature catches my respect in that it wasn't written "for me." I'm outside of who the writer was addressing. It's traveling without packing a suitcase.

Thank you to you and Mary Beth for the recommendations. I'm doing a reading challenge this year and one of the monthly challenges is to read a book written by someone outside of the United States. Both of the books you mentioned sound intriguing.

Add new comment

CAPTCHA

This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

The Lies We Live By

2/20/2024

Aristotle wrote a lot of important stuff, very little of which I’ve read. But this Aristotelian idea is cool and I don’t know why we are not taught this in high school. It helps untangle the importance of what we read and watch.

Fat Tuesday & Valentines Day & Ash Wednesday (says it all)

2/9/2024

I think today has to be a Three Things. You probably don’t even know I have Three Things scaffolding in my secret writing toolbox of organizational tools, but I do. Sometimes it’s how thoughts present themselves, you know? Things to say, but not for too long.

(Now that I've finished and read what I wrote, I guess this is five things but some days, in our expanding universe, the math just works this way,)

Successful & Failed Artists

 2/7/2024

Last week I finished reading Woodcutters by Thomas Bernhard. (I discovered this book via Librarian of Burgos Instagram because I am her fangirl now.)

If you like to read a book that has a recognizable plot of sympathetic characters moving forward through a problem to a solution– you will likely not enjoy this novel. Heck, I’m not sure if I ‘enjoyed’ it.

Animals of Winter

1/25/2024

Last week I invited you to submit pictures of animals who are visiting your life these days.

Who's In Your Backyard?

1/19/2024

It’s been a wowser of a wintery week. We had the deep and blowing snow last Friday which turned into the heavy-as-concrete snow on Saturday which turned into a deep and frozen crust on Sunday - and here we still are. Last week’s snow still limns the trees and branches. A foot of snow still covers every roof. When I walk (why yes, I’m still going out for strolls) it’s a matter of life and limb navigating the jagged piles between sidewalk and street. I do use my “Alpine” walking stick these days.

Change is coming but not today.

Joyriding the Snowstorm

1/12/2024

Today was one more day where my to-do list pretty much only had one big project on it which was “Write”. I’ve been working on a short story since the middle of December and here I still am, working on that story. I know more now than I did a month ago about what’s happening in it and I have a lot of written pages but none of them are done pages.

That was today’s sole agenda.

Then it snowed.

Tag Cloud

9/11 17 minutes 500 Words A-Z AARPtaxes AAUW abortion Acadia accident Accountable Advent aging Alaska animals anniversary antibiotics antlers apples appointments Arrows art Ashland August Augustine aunts baby Badlands balance Baldwin Barbara Barkskins Beauty Becky Becoming Esther Berry birthday bistro BLM Blue BookReport books Boxing Day boy scout Bread breakfast BreakfastClub BrokenDays BuyAngry Cabeza de Vaca Cahokia calendars Canada canoe cat romance cats cello Chicago China Choosing Christmas cilantro Cinnabuns circus climate change clouds Clowns clutter Colonialism comet ComfortZone CommonSense community consumerism Cops Corvid-19 Courage Covid-19 Crazy creditreport creosote crime CrimeShows danger DarkRiver death Debate December DecisionFatigue decluttering deer democracy dentist depression Destination Today Detroit Didion disasterprep distraction dogs dollhouse Dreams Duty Easter eBay Echoes Eclipse election EmilyDickinson eschatology Esquipulas exit polls eyes Fable FairTrade family farmer Fata Morgana ferns firealarm Fitness Five Flatbread Flexible flu Food Pantry Fort de Chartres frame Franc FrancGarcia friends frugal FrugalHacks Frugality frustration Ft.Ticonderoga fungi fusion Galena Gannets Garden GarfieldParkConservatory Gaspe genius geode GeorgeFloyd gerrymandering ghosts gifts girls GNTL gorgons goulash GovernorThompsonStatePark Graduation grandkids granola Grief groceries Guadalupe Guatemala gum guns Hair happiness HaveYouEver? hawks healthcare Healthinsurance hearings heart heaven HelleKBerry heroes hike History home HomeRepair Honduras Hope HowCrowGotOutofJail humor hurricane Ice Cream idiosyncrasy igloos impeachment Innkeeper Instincts integrity InternetPrivacy Interview InviteMe2Speak James Baldwin Jan 6 Janus jewelry JoyceAndrews Judy JulianofNorwich Jump justice Karen kites ladder Lady Lamb LangstonHuges LaphamPeak laundry LeeLeeMcKnight lemming Len lies Light Lincoln Little Women LockedOut Loki loneliness LouisArmstrong Love Ludington Macaw macho Manitoulin MargaretFuller Maria Hamilton Marquette marriage Marsden Hartley masks Mayan MayaWorks meme Memories men Middlemarch MilesWallyDiego MindfulChickens Mistakes MLK moon Mother MothersDay mounds mouser movies museums must-haves Mustapha NAMI Nancy Drew Newfoundland New Mexico New York City Nomadland nope observation OBUUC Ocotillo OnaJudge ordinary OscarRomero osprey Outside oximeter Parade mayhem PastorBettyRendon Paul Hessert PDQ Penny persimmon photos Pi Pies pineapples pizza poetry Preaching privacy procrastination Protest QE2 Quern quest Questions Rabbit holes racism reading recipe recipes recommendations Remember RepresentationMatters Reruns responsetoKapenga Retirement rhubarb Ricky rime RitesofPassage romance Rosemary Ruether Roses Roti Ruth SamaritanWoman Sanctuary Sandhillcranes Santuario de Chimayo SaraKurtz SaraRodriguez satellites sci-fi ScottSimon sculpture Seasons Sermon ServantsoftheQuest sewing Shepherd Shontay ShortStory shoulder sick sickness Slower snow Social Security SofritoBandito solstice South Dakota SpaceShuttle spirituality spring square feet St. Louis staining stars stele Stereotypes stories StoryStarts stream monitoring stress SUBSTACK Survival swim Talent taxes teenager thankgsgiving Thanksgiving TheBridge TheMaid ThePerpetualYou therapy ThreeBillBoards Three Thing Three Things ThreeThings TidalBore TimeBeing toddler Tom tortillas Trains travel Traveler Tubing turtle Twilight Bark Tyrone Ukraine Ulysses Grant Umbrella UnrelatedObservations Up North urgency vacation vaccine Valentines vanilla Vietnam vision VivianWokeUpDrowning Vocabulary vole volunteer WalkingAndSeeing Wampanaog war WarsanShire weather weaving Webs wedding whines WhyAttendChurch Wiley Willa WillaCather Wisteria Won! Wonder words Xeriscape Yellowstone Zebra
Ad Promotion